Brands

Brooks Glycerin vs Asics Nimbus: A Detailed Comparison [April 2019 UPDATE]

Last Updated on

Every runner wishes for a running shoe that could offer them optimum comfort and boost their efficiency while running. To make this wish come true, running shoe manufacturers are leaving no stones unturned in augmenting the running experience of athletes all over the world.

For different types of running, be it track running or road running, shoe brands are manufacturing specialized shoes based on the terrain and other basic running requirements such as a solid insole, adequate heel cushioning, etc. In this article, we’ll talk about two best-selling running shoes on the market – Brooks Glycerin and Asics Nimbus. We’ll compare the products in detail to help you pick the best running shoe.

[compare-two-products]

Brooks Glycerin vs Asics Nimbus

Two top-rated running shoe brands on the market are Brooks and ASICS. Both the brands never fail to amaze us with their thoughtful designs and unmatched features.

Brooks has been catering to the runners since 1914, whereas ASICS has been on the market ever since 1949. Having spent a considerable amount of time serving runners belonging to different categories; both these brands have a comprehensive understanding of what runners expect from their running shoes. Keeping the requirements in mind, both the brands have designed and produced some of the masterpieces in the running shoe space.

The most celebrated examples of their stupendous creations are Brooks Glycerin 17 and ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21. Both the running shoes are just fantastic in every way. Laden with features that always favor the runners on different types of terrains, these shoes have everything that runners like you are looking for.

Both the running shoes come with their set of pros and cons. After weighing both the shoes on several parameters, we have managed to draw an unbiased comparison between the two products.

Let’s now look at the detailed comparison between the first-rate models of Brooks and ASICS, i.e., Brooks Glycerin 17 and ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21.

And…. the comparison begins!

Let’s begin by comparing the basic specifications of the two models. The table below covers the basic specifications of the two running shoes. Take a look:

 Brooks Glycerin 17ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21 
Price $144.50 – $252.19 (Check out the latest rates here!)$119.61 – $294.33 (Check out the latest rates here!)
Heel to Toe Drop 10 mm 10 mm  
Forefoot Height 22mm 13 mm 
Heel Height 32mm 23 mm 
Upper Design Double jacquard mesh Gradient jacquard mesh 
Midsole Technology DNA Loft cushioning FlyteFoam/ FluidRide Technology 
Outsole Technology HPR Plus and blown rubber ASICS High Abrasion Rubber and blown rubber  
Sizing US: 7 to 12.5 US: 6 to 16 
Width Option Normal, Wide Normal, Wide  
Arch Support Neutral Neutral 
Terrain Road  Road  
Weight  10.60 oz. (301 gr.) 10.688 oz. (303 gr.) 
Release Date  June 2018 Dec 2017 

Now let’s deep dive into the remarkable features of each of these shoes.

Brooks Glycerin 17

Brooks is one of the leading brands when it comes to athletic shoes, especially running shoes. Everyone, from top-notch athletes to regular runners prefer using the Brooks running shoes for their running events as well as their daily running regime. This leading brand understands the tailored demands of the runners and manufactures shoes to enhance their performance and efficiency.

Paying a tremendous amount of attention to the technicalities associated with running, Brooks also pays attention to environmental sustainability. Time after time, the company brings out a new model or an upgrade.

Many publications have named Brooks as the “Best Running Shoe.” Here, we are reviewing Brooks Glycerin 17, one of the most popular Brooks running shoe.

Notable Features:

  • Offers great comfort while running
  • Stylish upper
  • A lightweight design
  • Upper unit is airy and breathable
  • Snugly sock-like fit
  • DNA Loft midsole technology offers a very soft and responsive ride
  • Use of two rubber materials in the outsole
  • Use of 3D Fit Print Technology on the upper
  • Ideal Pressure zone to release pressure

Sole Technology

  • Outsole Technology

The outsole of these stylish shoes is constructed using two robust rubber materials namely, the HPR Plus rubber and blown rubber.

Starting with the HPR Plus rubber, it covers the heel area. It is very durable and is responsible for protecting the outer sole unit from wear and abrasion. This works well for heel-strike runners. The rubber amazingly absorbs the impact and offers excellent traction on different kinds of surfaces.

The other kind of rubber, i.e., the blown rubber covers the forefoot area of the outsole. This rubber compound augments the traction and flexibility. It is very bouncy and soft and so, it adds up to the underfoot cushioning making the runner feel comfortable.

The most amazing feature about the outsole of Brooks Glycerin is the presence of the Ideal Pressure Zones. These zones help in dispersing the pressure and hence, offering a very smooth ride.

  • Midsole Technology

Coming to the midsole technology of the excellent Brooks Glycerin 16 shoes, it uses the latest DNA Loft cushioning. The predecessor of these running shoes used the Super DNA cushioning. As compared to the predecessors, this latest midsole technology is more responsive.

Brooks has always used the patented foam midsole. However, in Brooks Glycerin, the makers have used an upgraded and foam formula. The contemporary DNA Loft cushioning is an amalgamation of foam, rubber, as well as air. These three components come together to offer a very soft and amazingly comfortable cushioning to the wearer. The midsole ensures a better bounce, better responsiveness, and enhanced durability.

The DNA Loft cushioning provides a very smooth heel-to-toe transition. The continuous grooves used by Brooks further improve flexibility and responsiveness.

In the presence of plush cushioning, the biggest concern is a feeling of gaucherie. But on wearing these shoes, you will not feel clumsy at all. Even in the presence of plush cushioning, the shoes offer an excellent ground feel.

All in all, the sole unit provides a very smooth ride.

Upper

The upper of Brooks Glycerin is fabricated with double jacquard mesh. The upper material guarantees better breathability. The double layer mesh also does not let dirt enter the shoes and add more support.

The outer material stretches and conforms to the shape of the feet. This further assures a supremely comfortable coverage.

Furthermore, the 3D Fit Print Technology amps up the overall fit of Brooks Glycerin 16. The 3D print overlays support the feet through full gait. They offer more rigidity and keep the foot locked in.

For a better in-shoe feel, the manufacturers have used an internal bootie construction. The wider toe box ensures greater comfort. The use of the old-world lace-up closure ensures greater mid-foot security along with offering a complacent foot lock-down.

The plush collar hugs the ankle and the foot.

Weight

Given the amount of cushioning, it is very difficult for anyone to fathom lightweight running shoe. But, to your surprise, the shoes are quite light in weight. Of course, they are not featherlight but, not very clunky either.

The shoes are very comfortable and lightweight. Men’s shoes weigh 10.5 ounces, whereas women’s shoes weigh 9 ounces.

Breathability

The double-layered mesh along with the 3D printed overlays allows proper ventilation. Air circulates throughout the shoes making the wearer feel dry and comfortable throughout the run. This is a plus point for the runners who sweat profusely.

The upper mesh makes it possible to wear these shoes during the summer run. But this does not mean that you cannot wear these shoes in cold weather. They offer optimum protection for training in cold weather.

Comfort

Comfort and Brooks Glycerin 17 go hand in hand. The plush midsole and supportive upper come together to provide maximum comfort to the runner.

Durability

These running shoes are reliable and very durable. The outsole is very robust, the midsole is made from strong material, and the upper does not wear and tear easily. These shoes have a long shelf life.

Responsiveness

Generally, cushioning is always inversely proportional to responsive, but this is not the case with this shoe. Quite contrary to this belief, Brooks Glycerin 16 is far more responsive than the other Brook shoes. The new midsole offers exemplary energy return.

Protection

The plush cushioning brings down the impact. The presence of an Ideal Pressure Zone on the sole offers optimum protection from high impacts. The design helps in dissipating the impact on any kind of surface.

The mesh upper guarantees maximum protection against heat. The 3D print design promotes air flow and hence, prevents overheating.

Support and Stability

The sock-liner like fit makes sure that the runner gets optimum support while running. The heel collar snugly fits the heel and adds to the support.

The shoes offer a great amount of stability, especially to the neutral runners.

Traction

The rubber outsole assures superlative grip. Both the kinds of rubbers provide great traction on almost every kind of surface.

Style

Brooks Glycerin 17 is indeed a very stylish shoe. There are many color options both for females and males. For males, the color options available are black and orange, navy and neon, dark teal and neon, and blue.

For women, the available color options are black and pink, dark purple, pink, and teal.

The 3D print overlays do more than offering stability. They enhance the style quotient.

Size and Fit

These shoes are true to the size. They are available for many foot measurements. The heel, as well as forefoot areas, showcase a standard medium fit. The toe box is wide which adds to the comfort.

The sizing options available for men including D – Medium, 2E – Wide and that for women, including AA – Narrow, B – Medium, D – Wide.

Pros and Cons

Pros  Cons  
Presence of plush cushioning Insole moves from its position while running in wet conditions 
Enhanced flexibility Take longer duration of time to dry post wet runs 
Very comfortable upper  
Increased breathability  
Better traction on various surfaces  
Widened design offers a great stability  
Stylish   

ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21

ASICS has been in the game for many years and has always excelled. The running shoes by the brand always find themselves in the list of best performance shoes.

Paying attention to every minute detail, the brand always comes up with something new and exciting; whether it is a new technological feature or an upgraded style.

Let us take a look at one of the best-selling running shoes by ASICS, the ASICS GEL-Nimbus. The shoes are laden with multiple advanced technologies.

Notable features:

  • Very comfortable
  • ASICS High Abrasion Rubber in the outsole ensuring durability
  • Presence of DuraSponge compound in the outsole
  • FlyteFoam midsole
  • Use of FluidRide technology to get a smooth ride
  • Guidance Trusstic System in the midsole offering better structural integrity
  • Breathable Upper

Sole Technology

  • Outsole Technology

Asics GEL-Nimbus uses the AHAR or the ASICS High Abrasion Rubber in the outsole. This robust material is amazingly durable. Whatever the surface is, the outsole manages to face the paved surfaces without wear and tear. The sturdy outsole component extends the durability of the shoes.

The forefront section of these shoes is covered with the DuraSponge compound. This compound further enhances the durability. The presence of blown rubber in the outsole offers better cushioning.

  • Midsole Technology

The midsole of ASICS GEL-Nimbus incorporates Forefoot and Rearfoot Gel cushioning system. The system involves the use of the silicone-based gel. This gel absorbs all the impacts and shocks that are liable during a foot stride. The system offers a very smooth heel-to-toe transition. Hence, offering unbelievable comfort to the wearer.

The midsole of these shoes uses FlyteFoam which is around 55 percent lighter than the standard EVA foam. The FlyteFoam midsole gives a very responsive ride. It also contains organic fibers that further enhance the responsiveness and comfort.

To enhance the durability and add more cushioning to the midsole, the makers have used the FluidRide technology. Just like its name, the technology makes the ride very fluid. It also does not add weight to the shoes. Hence, the rider gets to enjoy an excellent ride without getting tired.

Furthermore, the midsole also features a flex groove. The vertically-placed groove is known as the Guidance line. As the name says, the line guides the foot to a more natural gait cycle. It enhances the natural gait cycle.

The Guidance Trusstic System is another support system that a runner gets in ASICS GEL-Nimbus. This lightweight system has two functions. One, it maintains the structural integrity of the midfoot and also, at the same time, it improves the gait efficiency.

Another important feature of the midsole unit is the presence of the ComforDry X-40 Sockliner. This particular feature does not allow microbial growth. This, in turn, keeps the odor away. The system also keeps the feet dry and fresh even during intense running sessions. It also adds to the cushioning.

Upper

The upper of ASICS GEL-Nimbus uses the gradient jacquard-mesh on the upper. The upper ensures outstanding breathability. The upper construction is seamless which causes absolutely no irritation on the skin.

By virtue of the FluidFit technology, the shoe allows for an unrestricted foot movement. The stretchable mesh easily stretches in different directions allowing free movements of the feet.

The upper of these shoes is adorned with 3D printed overlays. It also features external plastic which is basically a heel clutching system. This system keeps the heel in the correct place. The plastic system does not allow the shoes to get removed while running.
The discrete eyelets add to the overall comfort. The materials help in releasing the lace tension.

Weight

The ASICS GEL-Nimbus is a lightweight shoe. The midsole uses FlyteFoam, which is much lighter in weight than the traditional EVA foam.

The shoe for men weighs 10.688 oz. (303 gr.) and that of the women weighs 8.783 oz. (249 gr.).

Breathability

The gradient jacquard-mesh covering the upper fortifies breathability. The mesh construction facilitates easy flow of air inside the shoes.

Comfort

The ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21 is one of the most comfortable shoes by ASICS. Every feature of these shoes aims at enhancing the comfort.

The presence of Forefoot and Rearfoot Gel cushioning system in the midsole provides tremendous comfort. Other midsole technologies add on to comfort.

Durability

Durability is not at all an issue with these running shoes. ASICS High Abrasion Rubber makes it very durable. Furthermore, the robust blown rubber and DuraSponge on the outsole make sure that your shoes stay away from wear and tear.

Responsiveness

The ASICS GEL-Nimbusrunning shoes are very responsive. The presence of FlyteFoam midsole sees to it that the runner enjoys a very responsive ride. The organic fibers present in the foam add up to the responsiveness.

Protection

The outsole and the midsole together provide a great amount of protection to the feet even while running on a rugged terrain. The use of a sturdy rubber compound on the outsole and midsole technologies like silicon-based gel cushioning, FlyteFoam, and FluidRide technology come together to protect the feet from impact injuries.

Support and Stability

There are many excellent features in these shoes that promote support and stability. The Guidance Trusstic System offers excellent support and maintains the overall integrity.
The presence of foot-hugging sock liner keeps the foot stable. The heel clutching system also enhances the support and stability.

Traction

The shoes offer an excellent grip on various surfaces.

Style

When it comes to style, the ASICS GEL-Nimbus 21 is par excellence. It has very stylish and modish design features.

The mesh system along with the overlays improves the aesthetic features. The shoes are available in many color options for both, men and women.

Size and Fit

The manufacturers have offered the shoes in standard shoe measurements. If you often indulge in short, as well as extended, road running, these shoes are just for you. The width options for men include D – Medium, 4E – Extra Wide and for women, the available options are B – Medium, D – Wide.

Pros and Cons

Pros  Cons 
Very comfortable  The toe box is little narrow 
Eye-grabbing design Arch support is not enough 
True to size Stiff footbed 
Amazing support on the different surfaces  
Excellent cushioning  
Lightweight  
Perfect fit   
Offer a great traction  

The Final Lace: Brooks Glycerin vs Asics Nimbus

Both, Brooks Glycerin 16 and ASICS GEL-Nimbus 20 running shoes are excellent choices for runners.

Each comes with their set of advantages and disadvantages. However, after closely reviewing both running shoes, we highly recommend Brooks Glycerin 16 running shoes because of the immense stability they provide on different kinds of surfaces, and the superior quality and durability of the outsole material.

[compare-two-products]

Further read:

Leave a Reply